9 posts / 0 new
Last post
Zorrothefox
Zorrothefox's picture
Choppy

The tree plugin has stopped working at the spruce trees at the proto-tree farm, 1388 63 -557.  I have to chop the whole tree down by hand.

like0
Zorrothefox
Zorrothefox's picture
Actually...

Sometimes it works and sometimes it doesn't, for no reason I can figure out.  Very frustrating.

like0

Zorrothefox

SMagicBaconS
SMagicBaconS's picture
It stops working when trees

It stops working when trees are connected by leaves. So if one tree's leaves are touching another tree's leaves, it work work at all. 

like0

 

Zorrothefox
Zorrothefox's picture
Well poo

Actually that is not an invariable rule.  I have many times seen it work when trees are connected. ALL the trees at the proto-tree farm are connected with leaves, but only sometimes does the plugin fail.  It might be how MANY leaves make a connection?  More study is clearly needed. 

In any case I will ask users to please remove the entire tree by whatever means necessary.  You might have to actually chop the whole thing down.  Boo hoo.

like0

Zorrothefox

Treydun
Treydun's picture
Its on the list :S

Its on the list :S

like0

I am not afraid of an army of lions led by a sheep,
I am afraid of an army of sheep led by a lion. ~ Alexander the Great

ShoutingPanda
ShoutingPanda's picture
OK

Given my experience with the trees, When the leaves connect it does hurt the plug in, and it mistakes the tree as part of the tree it is touching. if there is a wood block from the tree that is close enough to the other tree through leaves within 1-3 blocks, then it will interfere. thats just my observation with acacia trees when i planted them 4 blocks apart.

like0
Zorrothefox
Zorrothefox's picture
maybe

Sounds like you've done some experiments Efeteh, which is better than me just shooting off my mouth.  ALL the trees at the Spruce part of the Zorro Tree Farm touch each other to a greater or lesser degree; sounds like you've figured out why this might make the plugin fail, depending on how much and how they are in contact.

 

like0

Zorrothefox

MoarPizzaPls
MoarPizzaPls's picture
The original plugin had

The original plugin had performance issues. If multiple trees touched, the plugin considered them to be one giant tree and would start chopping them all(and lag the server) instead of only the tree you wanted. From what I remember, I fixed this by adding some constraints to what is considered a tree by the plugin, including the maximum size of a tree. So if you have a tree that touches another tree(and that one perhaps touches other trees) then it might not work. I remember I also had a solution that worked when multiple trees were close to each other, but it left some logs floating in the air fairly often which was more annoying than the plugin not working in some cases.

Right now if you can't chop a tree down, remove some the leaves that connect it to another tree and then it's going to work again.

like0
Zorrothefox
Zorrothefox's picture
Good enough

It sounds like "fixing" Choppy might be a difficult task.  I just want to say that it usually works fine as it is, and I don't think asking people to just go ahead and cut down the whole tree in a FREE tree farm by hand once in a while, just as 98% of minecraft players always do, is asking too much.

like0

Zorrothefox